Thursday, December 1, 2016

Parashat Toldot: What Would You Do To Get a Blessing?

Sometimes I think that the Torah, in these early stories, presents us not with an ideal to follow, but more of a mirror to see more clearly our daily insanity.

I think that is the case with the fight over the blessings in this week’s parsha. The phrase that comes to mind here is the modern Israeli phrase, ad kedei kakh? “To that extent?” Really? Is being the first born so important that we would fight in the womb over it, holding on to the ankle of our brother? Is it so important that we would dress or dress our child up in his sibling’s clothing in an elaborate scheme to fool the father? Really?

To what end all this manipulating? What is it that they -- and we -- are out there fighting for all the time anyway? What is it we are climbing over each other to get? A blessing? Is that how one receives blessings? By fighting tooth and nail and furry skin over it? What are we in this rat race in the first place for? And is it getting us there? Or is it rather, as Yaakov suspects, bringing a curse down on us instead of a blessing, all this heel-chasing?

These parshiyyot do present a few glimpses of real blessing, and they do not come as a result of these schemes but from quiet moments of peace with God.

One occurs when Yitzhak, after being involved in his own contentious fights over the ownership of a well [itself a symbol of blessing], finally sees that “God has made things expansive for us,” naming this new well Rehovot, “Expansiveness.” This feeling of expansiveness -- that there is plenty of water for all to share – is the opposite mode of the heel-chasing fight over the blessing in the rest of the parsha. And it leads to a real sense of blessing and peace – following this event, God appears to Yitzhak and blesses him that He, God will be with him and always bless him, and then Avimelekh appears again to make a treaty and they all break a meal bshalom, in peace.

True blessing does not come from the fight.

For Yaakov, true blessing comes to him in the beginning of next week’s parsha. Running away from home with nothing but the clothes on his back, he lies down with a rock for a pillow and finally does get a real blessing, not from his father, but from God Himself, who stands over him with His ladder of angels and promises him to be with him and protect him on his way.

We chase blessing constantly through all kinds of manipulations. We worry that we will not get what we need unless we hold on tight to the ankle in front of us and sometimes we even betray our own true identity in search of this ostensible external blessing. This parsha makes me wonder whether such seeking is helpful or whether perhaps true blessing comes from those moments of internal peace, when we are calm enough and expansive enough to feel God's presence and simply know that we are always blessed.

8 comments:

  1. Yes. We learn best when we see them as real people in ways we can relate to. But if the protagonists are not always good (or perfect), then what prevents us from just re-writing the book in our own image? Perhaps honest engagement with what the Author is saying and what we think is the only avenue to Truth? (I hope this is somewhat coherent. :))

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. It feels like we have no choice but to use our best judgment and experience and just be careful that we are really seeking the truth. Your warning about rewriting in our own image is a good one. Thanks, Mordecai!

      Delete
  2. Today I re read some of Rabbi Larry Kushner's book, G-d is in this Place and i,I Did Not Know It. He suggests that if we live ethically following the first 9 commandments then our blessing will be to not covet because we will be fulfilled.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. May we all be blessed to feel fulfilled with our own blessing and not go seeking after someone else's. Thanks for that insight, Simma!

      Delete
  3. Yes, it is very hard to get quiet enough to see the blessings that are staring us in the face.Yaacov was given a dream so he could see them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed. Well said. We are blind. And it is so hard to quiet the noise in order to see the blessings. Thanks, Mitch!

      Delete
  4. But he was given the dream after the deceptions. Were the deceptions necessary to put him in the place of receiving the blessing? The reading was very disturbing this week, more than in other years. I think I really noticed how imperfect Jacob was. Given that the end was known, God intended for Jacob to be the bechor, did it justify his and his mother's means to help God accomplish it? The pshat seems to say so...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am not sure if he gets the ladder blessing in spite of or because of his stealing of Esau's blessing. I am inclined to think it is despite that action, that this is a kind of alternative blessing he gets directly from God so that he can learn . . . And we are all just learning after all. Thanks, Amy. I share your struggle.

      Delete